« Un «blog»? - sacre bleu! | Main | More "evolutionary" explanations based on studies of American college students »

February 3, 2006

Everything2: Wikipedia with attitudes

For those who like their encyclopedia entries with a bit of attitude and an unpredictable degree of bias, they might like Everything2. I do. Dating back to 1999, it's been around a lot longer than the Wikipedia (b. January 15, 2001). Each entry here has a single author who maintains his or her rights. Many are encyclopedic in genre, but the site also accepts essays, poetry, whatever. Many entries have a distinct point of view, as opposed to Wikipedia's number 1 rule: Neutral Point of View. It was started by the software developer who started Slashdot: "News for Nerds. Stuff that Matters." It includes a Slashdot-like system for ranking users and posts, but the site warns against taking it too seriously. (Introduction apge is here.)

Everything2 has the following self-definition, culled from various of its own pages:

The web is distributed hypertext covering infinite subjects.
everything2 is localized hypertext covering infinite subjects.
[...]
everything2 is the web's schizophrenic little brother.
[...]
E2 is really two things: the premiere instantiation of the Everything System, a nice database-driven postboard/weblog thingie which works like a Wiki only more so; and a pretty highly structured (in a low-key way) society of folks who like writing (actively and passively), pathos and (particularly) hypertext.
[...]
The Everything Web System is Another Dumb Perl-MySQL Web Content-Management System

One rises through the ranks from Initiate to Novice, etc. up to Pseudo-God and then - in a nice twist - Pedant, this highest authority on the site!

This adds up to a pleasant and amusingly self-deprecating self-representation typical of the tone throughout the site.

Compare, for example, entries from the two sites on a topic that caught my eye when randomly clicking out from some "write-up" on Everything2 I'd stumbled across via a Google search: Anne-Sophie Mütter.

The Wikipedia entry has been edited by apparently twenty separate individuals over the last eighteen months, with no apparent controversy (there is no discussion page at all), and the gradual accretion of images, facts, and a few corrections.

It runs as follows:

Anne-Sophie Mutter (born June 29, 1963) is a German violinist.

Born in Rheinfelden in Baden, Germany, she started playing the piano at age five. Shortly thereafter, she began playing the violin, studying with Erna Honigberger and Aida Stucki.

After winning several prizes, she was exempted from school to dedicate herself to her art. When she was 13, conductor Herbert von Karajan invited her to play with the Berlin Philharmonic. In 1977, she made her debut at the Salzburg Festival and with the English Chamber Orchestra under Daniel Barenboim.

At 15, Mutter made her first recording of the Mozart Third and Fifth Violin Concertos with von Karajan and the Berlin Philharmonic. The same year, she was named Artist of the Year.

In 1980, she made her American debut with the New York Philharmonic under Zubin Mehta. In 1985, at the age of 22, she was made an honorary fellow of the Royal Academy of Music (London) and head of its faculty of international violin studies. In 1988, she made a grand tour of Canada and the United States, playing for the first time at Carnegie Hall. In 1998 she played and recorded for CD and DVD the complete set of Beethoven's Violin Sonatas, accompanied by Lambert Orkis; these were broadcast on television in many countries.

Though her repertoire includes many classical works, Mutter is particularly known for her performances of modern music. A number of pieces have been especially written for or dedicated to her, including Witold Lutoslawski's Partita, Krzysztof Penderecki's Second Violin Concerto and Wolfgang Rihm's Gesungene Zeit ("Time Chant"). She has received various prizes, including several Grammys. She also owns two Stradivarius violins (The Emiliani of 1703, and the Lord Dunn-Raven of 1710).

She is married to the pianist and conductor André Previn.


The Everything2 entry, written by Gritchka, is as follows:
A German violinist with a warm, passionate, but precise tone.

Born on 29 June 1963 in Rheinfelden, she took up learning the violin at the age of five, and at the age of six won first prize in the Jugend Musiziert (Young Musician) competition, the youngest ever winner. She also won a prize as a pianist; then she won the same prizes in 1974, and was asked if she'd mind awfully not entering again. Her tutors included Henryk Szeryng.

She was taken up as a protégée (and of course prodigy) by Karajan in 1976. She made her Salzburg and London débuts the following year.

In new music, she is especially associated with the composer Witold Lutoslawski. Recently she has regularly paired with the pianist Lambert Orkis for many recitals and recordings of modern music, in a project called "Back to the Future".

She is quite a gift to a record producer, being stunningly beautiful, but unlike some whose name mae not be mentioned, she is one of the most solidly talented of all violinists around, and the business with the dark flowing dresses and bare arms is just a bonus for the viewers. From watching her perform, I would say she gets quite as excited by the music as we her audience do.

Mutter is reticent about her private life; I believe her husband Dr Detlef Wunderlich died in a car crash, leaving her with a young child. (News! On or about 1 August 2002 she married the ageing conductor André Previn in a secret ceremony in Germany; his fifth marriage, the lucky swine.) She is a guest teacher at the Royal Academy of Music in London.

"Ten years from now, thirty years from now, I want more or less to be doing the same thing. Just better."

Updated 18 August 2001 to the spiky strains of the Prokofiev sonata in D major


This entry has no references, other than internal links to term-related stories, although many pages do include them. It's hard to assess the factual value of the piece, a common complaint about the Wikipedia. Wikipedia entries can be judged by the amount of behind-the-scenes activity and the quality of the meta-debate on the discussion page. On Everything2, you take your chances. It's often amusing writing, at least.

Posted by johnn at February 3, 2006 10:25 AM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.anthroblogs.org/mt/mt-tb.cgi/279

Comments

Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Remember me?